The decision comes after Handler’s well-received guest-hosting stint earlier this year, where her playful teasing of contestants like John Mulaney and Tiffany Haddish went viral. Sony Pictures Television executives praised her ability to balance the show’s intellectual rigor with comedic spontaneity, calling her “the perfect bridge between Jeopardy!’s legacy and the chaos of celebrity egos.” Handler will continue her stand-up tour and podcast while taping the series, which films in California this fall. Rumor has it she’s already lobbying for categories like “Recovering From Scandals” and “Things You Should’ve Googled Before Answering.”

Fans and former contestants had mixed reactions online. Ken Jennings, Jeopardy!’s other primary host, tweeted, “Welcome to the family, Chelsea. Watch out for the Daily Double—it’s a trap.” Meanwhile, celebrities like Amy Schumer and Dax Shepard commented with faux outrage, demanding “special treatment” if they compete. Handler, never one to shy away from controversy, quipped in her press statement: “If you’re a celebrity who can’t name the three branches of government, maybe sit this one out.”

Handler’s hiring signals a bold new direction for Celebrity Jeopardy!, leaning further into its status as a comedy-adjacent event rather than a straight-laced trivia competition. With her at the helm, the show is poised to become even more of a watercooler moment, blending smarts with Handler’s signature “no fcks given”* vibe. As one ABC exec put it: “Imagine SNL crossed with a Harvard quiz bowl—that’s the Chelsea effect.” The new season premieres this winter, and if Handler’s past is any indication, expect fireworks—or at least a few contestants regretting their life choices.