Trump’s remarks over the weekend about targeting Chicago for enhanced law enforcement measures also drew sharp criticism from Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker, who labeled the proposal a “manufactured crisis.” Both Johnson and Pritzker, Democrats, have publicly downplayed the severity of Chicago’s crime issues, despite increasing pressure and alarming statistics.

Mayor Johnson emphasized the city’s values and dismissed federal involvement, arguing that federal agents “don’t have police power.” He cited solidarity with other Democratic leaders like Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass in opposing what he called authoritarian tactics, and insisted that Chicago would respond with legal and civic action if the federal government interferes.

In contrast, a White House press release included statistics that paint a bleak picture of crime in Chicago. For 13 consecutive years, Chicago has recorded the highest number of murders among U.S. cities, and in 2024, its murder rate per capita is several times higher than cities like Los Angeles, New York, Islamabad, and Delhi. Arrest rates remain low, and gun violence and car thefts are on the rise.