Caprio, from Rhode Island, gained international fame through his hit show Caught in Providence, where his patient and empathetic handling of cases captured the hearts of millions. The program, which featured real people appearing before him for traffic violations, parking tickets, and other minor infractions, became a global sensation with billions of views across social media.

Often called the “nicest judge in the world,” Caprio became a symbol of fairness balanced with humanity. His lighthearted jokes, understanding approach, and ability to see beyond the charges made him stand out in a profession often viewed as stern and uncompromising.

Just a day before his passing, Caprio shared a heartfelt video message with his more than 2 million Instagram followers. In it, he thanked supporters for their prayers during his illness and asked to be remembered in their thoughts once again. “Last year I asked you to pray for me, and it’s very obvious that you did, because I came through a very difficult period. Unfortunately, I’ve had a setback, I’m back in the hospital. Now, I’m coming to you again and asking you to remember me in your prayers once more,” he said.

Caprio leaves behind his wife of 60 years, Joyce, along with their five children—Frank, David, Marissa, John, and Paul—seven grandchildren, and two great-grandchildren.